All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Football Committee
| FIRST-TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Justin Bland | College of DuPage | Fr. | |||
| RB | Rashad Madden | Minnesota State Community and Technical College | So. | |||
| RB | Jamareon Dale | College of DuPage | So. | |||
| WR | Marlon Fluker | Minnesota West Community & Technical College | Fr. | |||
| WR | Clayton Bone | College of DuPage | Fr. | |||
| TE | Jabari Rone | Louisburg College | Fr. | |||
| OL | Greg Fotinopoulos | College of DuPage | So. | |||
| OL | Corey Williams | Louisburg College | R-So. | |||
| OL | Josh Noble | Minnesota West Community and Technical College | So. | |||
| OL | Grant Lyons | North Dakota State College of Science | So. | |||
| OL | Armend Ujkashi | College of DuPage | So. | |||
| FIRST-TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Javieane Stevens | Rochester Community and Technical College | Fr. | |||
| DL | Mason Pagel | North Dakota State College of Science | So. | |||
| DL | Darion Johnson | College of DuPage | So. | |||
| DL | Jakub Mwangelwa | College of DuPage | Fr. | |||
| LB | Samuel Miller | North Dakota State College of Science | So. | |||
| LB | Letraskey Pressley | Louisburg College | Fr. | |||
| LB | Stephon Chapmon | Minnesota State Community and Technical College | So. | |||
| DB | Malique Jackson | North Dakota State College of Science | So. | |||
| DB | Jamal Drummond | Erie Community College | Fr. | |||
| DB | Joanue Morten-Berry | Louisburg College | Fr. | |||
| DB | Jaden Leonard | Minnesota State Community and Technical College | Fr. | |||
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| K | Christian Casillas | College of DuPage | So. | |||
| P | Aaron Rice | College of DuPage | Fr. | |||
| RS | Trevion Carothers | North Dakota State College of Science | So. | |||
| SECOND-TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Cameron Harbaugh | Hudson Valley Community College | So. | |||
| RB | Ernest Temple | College of DuPage | So. | |||
| RB | Mekiaun Davis | Louisburg College | Fr. | |||
| WR | Jaylen Williams | Rochester Community and Technical College | Fr. | |||
| WR | Micah Gates | Hudson Valley Community College | Fr. | |||
| TE | Luke Bonnema | College of DuPage | Fr. | |||
| OL | Benjamin Kilgore | Hudson Valley Community College | So. | |||
| OL | Tom Henderson | Minnesota State Community and Technical College | Fr. | |||
| OL | Dennis Lutchoomun | Minnesota North College-Mesabi Range | So. | |||
| OL | David Myers | Nassau Community College | Fr. | |||
| OL | Aaron Phillips | College of DuPage | So. | |||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Benjamin Mann | Nassau Community College | Fr. | |||
| DL | Keaton Braddock | Louisburg College | Fr. | |||
| DL | Alexander Hedhili | Hudson Valley Community College | So. | |||
| DL | Jamari Jefferson | College of DuPage | Fr. | |||
| LB | Leonardo Lopez | Nassau Community College | Fr. | |||
| LB | Michael Tringali | College of DuPage | Fr. | |||
| LB | Shamar Adams | Erie Community College | So. | |||
| DB | Mason Montgomery | College of DuPage | Fr. | |||
| DB | Kamal Thames | Louisburg College | Fr. | |||
| DB | Vincent Spina | Nassau Community College | Fr. | |||
| DB | Khamrin Boecker | College of DuPage | Fr. | |||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| K | Rashdan Tebyasa | Rochester Community and Technical College | So. | |||
| P | Jaydon Manteufel | Minnesota State Community and Technical College | So. | |||
| RS | Markiss Nelson | Louisburg College | So. | |||
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Dylan Trevillian | Louisburg College | So. | |||
| QB | Jonathan Mosley | Minnesota North College-Mesabi Range | So. | |||
| RB | JaCori Luckey | Central Lakes College-Brainerd | Fr. | |||
| WR | Trevion Carothers | North Dakota State College of Science | So. | |||
| OL | Gabriel Coveny | Louisburg College | So. | |||
| OL | Ryan Lavoi | Rochester Community and Technical College | So. | |||
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Brysen McLeod | Minnesota North College - Mesabi Range | So. | |||
| DL | Marques Boddie | College of DuPage | So. | |||
| LB | William Sierra | College of DuPage | Fr. | |||
| LB | Antonio Hunt | Minnesota North College - Mesabi Range | So. | |||
| DB | Jamarion Johnson | College of DuPage | Fr. | |||
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| LS | Andrew Kallas | College of DuPage | Fr. | |||