All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Football Committee
| FIRST-TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Graedyn Buell | North Dakota SCS | So. | |||
| HB | Rondarius Gregory | Minnesota State CTC | So. | |||
| HB | Samson Zander | DuPage (IL) | Fr. | |||
| WR | Andreus Griffin | MN North-Mesabi Range | So. | |||
| WR | Marselio Mendez | North Dakota SCS | So. | |||
| TE | Paul Meyer | Central Lakes (MN) | So. | |||
| OL | Byron Hill | Louisburg (NC) | So. | |||
| OL | Kwame Frimpong | Nassau (NY) | So. | |||
| OL | Rudy Glancey | Minnesota State CTC | So. | |||
| OL | Dagen Miller | DuPage (IL) | Fr. | |||
| OL | Ethan Lyons | North Dakota SCS | So. | |||
| FIRST-TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Trevor Smith | Hudson Valley (NY) | So. | |||
| DL | Byron Puryear | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| DL | Michael Simon | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| DL | Sylvester Ware | Rochester (MN) | So. | |||
| LB | Christian Ozolins | Erie (NY) | Fr. | |||
| LB | Chris Heidl | Minnesota State CTC | Fr. | |||
| LB | Joseph Holmes | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| DB | Guy Goss | DuPage (IL) | Fr. | |||
| DB | Kristian Hernandez | Nassau (NY) | Fr. | |||
| DB | Joseph Tarnue | Rochester (MN) | So. | |||
| DB | De'vonta Roberts | Rochester (MN) | So. | |||
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| K | Carsen McKnight | Minnesota State CTC | So. | |||
| P | Morgan Smith | Hocking (OH) | Fr. | |||
| RS | John Beaubrun | Nassau (NY) | So. | |||
| SECOND-TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Gavin Sukup | DuPage (IL) | Fr. | |||
| HB | Joshua Jean-Baptiste | Hudson Valley (NY) | So. | |||
| HB | Jaden McGill | DuPage (IL) | Fr. | |||
| WR | John Beaubrun | Nassau (NY) | So. | |||
| WR | Matthew Brown | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| TE | Parker Grimes | DuPage (IL) | Fr. | |||
| OL | Christopher Alabanzas | Hudson Valley (NY) | So. | |||
| OL | Shamar Riley | Nassau (NY) | So. | |||
| OL | Gavin Layton | Rochester (MN) | Fr. | |||
| OL | Kendall Nellem | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| OL | Xavier Smith | MN North-Mesabi Range | Fr. | |||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Jordan Campbell | Nassau (NY) | So. | |||
| DL | Preston Yohnke | North Dakota SCS | Fr. | |||
| DL | Danny Disterhaft | Minnesota State CTC | So. | |||
| DL | Nicholas Korom | Central Lakes (MN) | So. | |||
| LB | Teddy Wilson | Louisburg (NC) | So. | |||
| LB | Jaden Martinez | Nassau (NY) | So. | |||
| LB | Cameron Tibbetts | MN North-Mesabi Range | So. | |||
| DB | Danarius Shaw | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| DB | Rashad Sherwood | Central Lakes (MN) | Fr. | |||
| DB | Deshawn Carter | Minnesota State-CTC | So. | |||
| DB | Alieu Conteh | Minnesota State-CTC | So. | |||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| K | Thomas Zabransky | Nassau (NY) | Fr. | |||
| P | Nik Hunchak | North Dakota SCS | So. | |||
| RS | Joshua Jean-Baptiste | Hudson Valley (NY) | So. | |||