All-America honors are presented to the top five finishers in each weight class at the NJCAA Wrestling Championship
Champion = First Team | Runner-up = Second Team | 3rd Place = Third Team | 4th/5th Place = Honorable Mention
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| WEIGHT | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | ||
| 125# | Ane'e Vigil | Clackamas (OR) | So. | ||
| 133# | Gavin Bauder | Clackamas (OR) | Fr. | ||
| 141# | Gavyn Whitehead | Indian Hills (IA) | Fr. | ||
| 149# | Keith Smith | Southeast (NE) | So. | ||
| 157# | Job Lee | Fort Hays Tech Northwest (KS) | So. | ||
| 165# | Malton Powe | Pratt (KS) | So. | ||
| 174# | Otgonbayar Batsuuri | Fort Hays Tech Northwest (KS) | So. | ||
| 184# | Lazaro Crespo | Fort Hays Tech Northwest (KS) | So. | ||
| 197# | Andrew Marquez | Indian Hills (IA) | Fr. | ||
| 285# | Dmarian Lopez | Western Wyoming | So. | ||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| WEIGHT | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | ||
| 125# | Sefton Douglass | Western Wyoming | So. | ||
| 133# | Drew Cooper | Iowa Central | Fr. | ||
| 141# | Dmitri Alarcon | Western Wyoming | Fr. | ||
| 149# | Tommy Dalton | Western Wyoming | Fr. | ||
| 157# | Henry Dillingham | Clackamas (OR) | Fr. | ||
| 165# | Asadbek Fayzullaev | Northwest (WY) | Fr. | ||
| 174# | Mohamed Tarek Abdelhady | Indian Hills (IA) | Fr. | ||
| 184# | Jaquan East | Indian Hills (IA) | So. | ||
| 197# | Coen Grimm | Iowa Central | Fr. | ||
| 285# | Jeisser Sampson-Sanchez | Fort Hays Tech Northwest (KS) | Fr. | ||
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| WEIGHT | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | ||
| 125# | Elijah Cater | North Idaho | So. | ||
| 133# | Tegan Sherk | Ridgewater (MN) | Fr. | ||
| 141# | Cesar Avelar | Clackamas (OR) | So. | ||
| 149# | Sam Silveria | North Idaho | So. | ||
| 157# | Brice Coleman | Indian Hills (IA) | So. | ||
| 165# | Kaden King | Iowa Central | Fr. | ||
| 174# | Leo Tukhlynovych | Rochester (MN) | So. | ||
| 184# | Isaac White | Southeast (NE) | So. | ||
| 197# | Austin Richens | Northwest (WY) | Fr. | ||
| 285# | Jett Swain | Northwest (WY) | So. | ||
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| WEIGHT | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | ||
| 125# | Riley Bettich | Indian Hills (IA) | So. | ||
| 125# | Logan Crawford | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | Fr. | ||
| 133# | Amantee Mills | Andrew (GA) | Fr. | ||
| 133# | Sean-Michael Gonzalez | Carl Albert State (OK) | Fr. | ||
| 141# | Colby Klinger | Southwestern Michigan | So. | ||
| 141# | Evan Rodriguez | Cowley (KS) | Fr. | ||
| 149# | Ashton Hayhurst | Triton (IL) | So. | ||
| 149# | Shehabeldin Mohamed | Indian Hills (IA) | Fr. | ||
| 157# | Ayson Rice | Southeast (NE) | Fr. | ||
| 157# | Davion King | Labette (KS) | So. | ||
| 165# | Cinsere Clark | Indian Hills (IA) | Fr. | ||
| 165# | Emmanuel Celestin | North Iowa Area | So. | ||
| 174# | Deontre Buttram | Carl Albert State (OK) | Fr. | ||
| 174# | Lawrence Rosario | Iowa Central | So. | ||
| 184# | Chandler Thompson | Snow (UT) | So. | ||
| 184# | Julian Gorring | Clackamas (OR) | So. | ||
| 197# | Matthew Marcum | Labette (KS) | So. | ||
| 197# | Ghee Rachal | Triton (IL) | So. | ||
| 285# | Ray Griffin | North Idaho | Fr. | ||
| 285# | Ryan Boersma | Triton (IL) | Fr. | ||