All-America honors are presented to the top five finishers in each weight class at the NJCAA Wrestling Championship
Champion = First Team | Runner-up = Second Team | 3rd Place = Third Team | 4th/5th Place = Honorable Mention
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| WEIGHT | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | ||
| 125# | Ane'e Vigil | Clackamas | Fr. | ||
| 133# | Cody Phelps | Western Wyoming | So. | ||
| 141# | Malachi Bordovsky | Iowa Western | So. | ||
| 149# | Matt Sarbo | Iowa Central | So. | ||
| 157# | Darnal Heard | Iowa Central | So. | ||
| 165# | Austin Raby | Clackamas | RSo. | ||
| 174# | Otgonbayar Batsuuri | Northwest Kansas Tech | Fr. | ||
| 184# | Aziz Fayzullaev | Northwest | So. | ||
| 197# | Kaden Glass | Pratt | So. | ||
| 285# | CJ Carter | Iowa Western | Fr. | ||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| WEIGHT | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | ||
| 125# | Bridger Ricks | Western Wyoming | So. | ||
| 133# | Cesar Avelar | Clackamas | Fr. | ||
| 141# | Easton Taylor | Pratt | So. | ||
| 149# | Jaden Two Lance | Carl Albert State | RFr. | ||
| 157# | Kristopher Ketchum | Nassau | So. | ||
| 165# | Cayleb Atkins | Pratt | RFr. | ||
| 174# | Isaac White | Southeast | Fr. | ||
| 184# | Darion Johnson | Western Wyoming | So. | ||
| 197# | Luke MacDonald | Iowa Western | So. | ||
| 285# | Cody Pinkerton | Northwest | RSo. | ||
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| WEIGHT | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | ||
| 125# | Anthony Schickel | Triton | So. | ||
| 133# | Jordan Oehme | Southeast | Fr. | ||
| 141# | River Wardle | Western Wyoming | So. | ||
| 149# | Cordell White | North Iowa Area | Fr. | ||
| 157# | Porter Craig | North Idaho | Fr. | ||
| 165# | Leo Tukhlynovych | Rochester | Fr. | ||
| 174# | Lawrence Rosario | Iowa Central | Fr. | ||
| 184# | Blake Jouret | Pratt | So. | ||
| 197# | Connor Lorden | Harper | Fr. | ||
| 285# | Dmarian Lopez | Western Wyoming | Fr. | ||
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| WEIGHT | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | ||
| 125# | Kaden Spragis | Pratt | So. | ||
| 125# | Joseph Petrone | Nassau | So. | ||
| 133# | Paul Ruff | Iowa Western | So. | ||
| 133# | Arojae Hart | Indian Hills | So. | ||
| 141# | Isaac Church | North Iowa Area | So. | ||
| 141# | Cole Holien | Ridgewater | So. | ||
| 149# | Cohen Wiste | Rochester | Fr. | ||
| 149# | Reggie Raiz | Clackamas | Fr. | ||
| 157# | Chris Lopez | Western Wyoming | So. | ||
| 157# | Ayden Kingery | Indian Hills | Fr. | ||
| 165# | Orrin Jackson | Northwest | RSo. | ||
| 165# | Chance Davis | Cowley | Fr. | ||
| 174# | Conan Northwind | North Idaho | Fr. | ||
| 174# | Paul Ortiz | Clackamas | RSo. | ||
| 184# | Lazaro Crespo | Northwest Kansas Tech | Fr. | ||
| 184# | Anthony Tuttle | Rochester | So. | ||
| 197# | Bradley Whitright | North Idaho | So. | ||
| 197# | Ghee Rachal | Triton | So. | ||
| 285# | Rylee Creasey | Snow | Fr. | ||
| 285# | Andreas Barnett | Minnesota North-Itasca | Fr. | ||