All-America honors are presented to the top five finishers in each weight class at the NJCAA Wrestling Championship
Champion = First Team | Runner-up = Second Team | 3rd Place = Third Team | 4th/5th Place = Honorable Mention
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| WEIGHT | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | ||
| 125# | Garrett Ricks | Western Wyoming | So. | ||
| 133# | Jovan Garcia | Southwestern Oregon | Fr. | ||
| 141# | Jacob Mitchell | Pratt (KS) | So. | ||
| 149# | Keaton Geerts | Iowa Central | So. | ||
| 157# | Alex Ramirez | Clackamas (OR) | Fr. | ||
| 165# | Christian Minto | North Iowa Area | So. | ||
| 174# | Josh Kenny | Muskegon (MI) | Fr. | ||
| 184# | Josh McFarland | Iowa Western | So. | ||
| 197# | Jose Valdez | North Iowa Area | So. | ||
| 285# | Jorden Pryor | Iowa Central | So. | ||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| WEIGHT | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | ||
| 125# | Jakason Burks | Iowa Western | Fr. | ||
| 133# | Justin Mejia | Clackamas (OR) | Fr. | ||
| 141# | Marckis Branford | Clackamas (OR) | So. | ||
| 149# | Jacob Beeson | Pratt (KS) | So. | ||
| 157# | Fabian Padilla | Iowa Western | Fr. | ||
| 165# | Steele Starren | Clackamas (OR) | Fr. | ||
| 174# | Jose Rodriguez | Iowa Central | So. | ||
| 184# | Deron Pulliam | Indian Hills (IA) | Fr. | ||
| 197# | Massoma Endene | Iowa Lakes | Fr. | ||
| 285# | Devon Dawson | Pratt (KS) | So. | ||
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| WEIGHT | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | ||
| 125# | N/A | N/A | N/A | ||
| 133# | Caleb Meekins | Indian Hills (IA) | Fr. | ||
| 141# | Creighton Baughman | Iowa Western | Fr. | ||
| 149# | Victor Jacinto | Clackamas (OR) | Fr. | ||
| 157# | Nolan Miller-Johnston | Iowa Central | So. | ||
| 165# | Mirzo Khayitov | Ellsworth (IA) | Fr. | ||
| 174# | Christian Smoot | Western Wyoming | Fr. | ||
| 184# | Tyce Raddon | Western Wyoming | So. | ||
| 197# | Zach Ferris | Cloud County (KS) | So. | ||
| 285# | Dan Baker | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | So. | ||
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| WEIGHT | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | ||
| 125# | N/A | N/A | N/A | ||
| 125# | Nick DiGiacomo | RCSJ-Gloucester (NJ) | So. | ||
| 133# | Dalen Moore | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | So. | ||
| 133# | Ryan Smith | Cowley (KS) | So. | ||
| 141# | Parker Dobrocky | Rochester (MN) | So. | ||
| 141# | Quentrevion Campbell | North Iowa Area | So. | ||
| 149# | Dylan Brown | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | So. | ||
| 149# | Nathan Lendt | Ellsworth (IA) | Fr. | ||
| 157# | William VonRuden | Rochester (MN) | Fr. | ||
| 157# | Alfonso Martinez | North Idaho | Fr. | ||
| 165# | Ledger Petracek | North Idaho | Fr. | ||
| 165# |
Damon Ashworth
|
Minnesota West | Fr. | ||
| 165# | Adam Busiello | Nassau (NY) | Fr. | ||
| 174# | Dayton Fields | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | So. | ||
| 174# | Ein Carlos | North Iowa Area | Fr. | ||
| 184# | Devin Winston | North Idaho | Fr. | ||
| 184# | Jackson White | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | Fr. | ||
| 197# | Demarco Lee | Harper (IL) | So. | ||
| 197# | Michael Gasper | Clackamas (OR) | Fr. | ||
| 285# | Cohle Feliciano | North Idaho | So. | ||
| 285# | Shane Whitney | Camden County (NJ) | Fr. | ||