All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division III Softball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| P | Jenna Plue | Corning (NY) | So. | |
| P | Morgan Strickland | Patrick & Henry (VA) | So. | |
| P | Grace Folkema | North Dakota SCS | Fr. | |
| C | Avery Martin | North Dakota SCS | So. | |
| INF | Olivia Friend | Herkimer (NY) | So. | |
| INF | Kacey Triplett | Caldwell Tech (NC) | Fr. | |
| INF | Laila Rodriguez | Patrick & Henry (VA) | Fr. | |
| UTL | Morgan Boyd | Northampton (PA) | Fr. | |
| OF | Kaylin McDonald | Suffolk County (NY) | So. | |
| OF | Kaylin Nepton | Middlesex (NJ) | So. | |
| OF | TK Landes | North Dakota SCS | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| P | Gemma Galloway | RCSJ Gloucester (NJ) | So. | |
| P | Isabelle Curry | Caldwell Tech (NC) | So. | |
| C | Rachael Gooch | Patrick & Henry (VA) | Fr. | |
| INF | Mollie Reece | RCSJ Cumberland (NJ) | So. | |
| INF | Kaitlyn Geschwill | Central Lakes-Brainerd (MN) | Fr. | |
| INF | Brianna Greenlaw | Corning (NY) | Fr. | |
| DP | Anna Siter | Hudson Valley (NY) | Fr. | |
| UTL | Caroline Courson | Corning (NY) | So. | |
| OF | Abigail Collins | DuPage (IL) | So. | |
| OF | Kiannah Ward | Jefferson (NY) | So. | |
| OF | Jillian Fay | Brookdale (NJ) | Fr. | |