All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division I Softball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| P | Cailyn Heyl | Northwest Florida State | FR | |
| P | J'Dah Girigorie | Indian River State (FL) | FR | |
| P | Katia Reyes | McLennan (TX) | SO | |
| P | Tori Coffman | Walters State (TN) | SO | |
| C | Adelyn Becerra | Temple (TX) | SO | |
| INF | Trinity Allen | McLennan (TX) | FR | |
| INF | Tessa Hokanson | Southern Idaho | SO | |
| INF | Lydia Kirby | Volunteer State (TN) | FR | |
| INF | Arriana Wright | San Jacinto (TX) | SO | |
| INF | Sister Arnold | Northwest Florida State | FR | |
| OF | Taylor Meier | McLennan (TX) | SO | |
| OF | Mason Barclay | Odessa (TX) | FR | |
| OF | Megan Loftis | Central Florida | SO | |
| OF | Haley Hughes | Blinn (TX) | FR | |
| UTL | Bailey Marvin | Salt Lake (UT) | SO | |
| DP | Angelica Ortiz | Luna (NM) | SO | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| P | Bryanna French | Lake Land (IL) | SO | |
| P | Macie LaRue | Bossier Parish (LA) | SO | |
| P | Emma Lovato | Midland (TX) | FR | |
| P | Shelbee Jones | Salt Lake (UT) | FR | |
| C | Lauren Lee | Northeastern (CO) | SO | |
| INF | Camilia Zepeda | Pima (AZ) | SO | |
| INF | Tyerra Kaaialii | Odessa (TX) | SO | |
| INF | Olivia Sandoval | Hutchinson (KS) | SO | |
| INF | Greenlee Wells | Eastern Oklahoma | SO | |
| INF | Hailey Scott | Central Florida | SO | |
| OF | Cassidy Patterson | Indian River State (FL) | SO | |
| OF | Kailey Dixon | Walters State (TN) | SO | |
| OF | Madison Garcia | McLennan (TX) | FR | |
| OF | Katie Davis | Volunteer State (TN) | SO | |
| UTL | Raylea Parsons | North Central Texas | SO | |
| DP | Karlie Barba | Galveston (TX) | SO | |
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| P | Sami Huck | Jefferson (MO) | SO | |
| P | Lea Chevrier | Florida SouthWestern | SO | |
| P | Torie Sandoval | Trinidad State (CO) | SO | |
| P | Haley Crawford | Temple (TX) | FR | |
| C | Cydnee Schnieder | Iowa Western | SO | |
| INF | Miranda Mansfield | Salt Lake | SO | |
| INF | Arene Landon-Lane | Crowder (MO) | FR | |
| INF | Claire Lopez | Butler (KS) | FR | |
| INF | Courtney Christiansen | Southern Idaho | FR | |
| INF | Laney McGee | Abraham-Baldwin (GA) | SO | |
| OF | Mikaela Coburn | John A. Logan (IL) | FR | |
| OF | Larissa Siders | Florence-Darlington (SC) | FR | |
| OF | Lily Garcia | Temple (TX) | FR | |
| OF | Ashlyn Shirah | Northwest Florida State | SO | |
| UTL | Laura Leigh Wheeler | Wallace State (AL) | SO | |
| DP | Alex Stoner | Iowa Western | SO | |