All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division III Softball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| P | Katelyn Strauss | North Dakota SCS | So. | |
| P | Jayden Hill | Corning (NY) | So. | |
| C | Maggiemay Murrins | Niagara County (NY) | So. | |
| INF | Grace Vondracek | Corning (NY) | So. | |
| INF | Emma Imdieke | St. Cloud Tech (MN) | So. | |
| INF | Lexi Wood | Corning (NY) | So. | |
| OF | Emma Bright | Anoka-Ramsey (MN) | So. | |
| OF | Jaden Thompson | Suffolk County (NY) | So. | |
| OF | Alyssa Sigler | Brookdale (NJ) | So. | |
| DP | Avery Martin | North Dakota SCS | Fr. | |
| UTL | Mallory Shevlin | Brookdale (NJ) | Fr. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| P | Amber Dasenbrock | DuPage (IL) | So. | |
| P | Gemma Galloway | RCSJ Gloucester (NJ) | Fr. | |
| P | Molly Gross | Anoka-Ramsey (MN) | So. | |
| INF | Danielle King | Patrick & Henry (VA) | So. | |
| INF | Alyssa Beechler | Delta (MI) | So. | |
| INF | Emily MacGilbeny | RCSJ Gloucester (NJ) | So. | |
| OF | Angeline Montanez | Herkimer (NY) | So. | |
| OF | Kelsey Warren | DuPage (IL) | So. | |
| OF | Dana Medlar | RCSJ Gloucester (NJ) | Fr. | |
| DP | Grace Talbut | Corning (NY) | So. | |
| UTL | Lexie Tatro | MN North-Itasca | Fr. | |