| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Ben Nyberg | CCBC Essex (MD) | A | So. | |
| Tehokwirathe Barreiro | Onondaga (NY) | A/M | Fr. | |
| Tyler Kuprianchik | Nassau (NY) | M | Fr. | |
| Kohl Wesner | Harford (MD) | M | Fr. | |
| Christian LeFeurve | Genesee (NY) | A | So. | |
| Jack Lepore | Nassau (NY) | A | Fr. | |
| Carson Crawford | Harford (MD) | SSDM | Fr. | |
| Ryan Sweiderk | Harford (MD) | LSM | Fr. | |
| Owen Fasulka | CCBC Essex (MD) | A | So. | |
| Brayden Olstad | Harford (MD) | D | Fr. | |
| Luke Smeader | Genesee (NY) | M | Fr. | |
| Bradley David | CCBC Essex | M | So. | |
| Alex Epple | Harford (MD) | G | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Wyatt Barnard | Onondaga (NY) | A | Fr. | |
| Christian Maisel | Nassau (NY) | M | So. | |
| Josh Kubicki | DuPage (IL) | M | So. | |
| Teharonhiorens McComber | Onondaga (NY) | M | So. | |
| Brady Dolan | Nassau (NY) | A | Fr. | |
| Brian Freeman | Genesee (NY) | A | Fr. | |
| R.Kelly Trajean | Nassau (NY) | M | So. | |
| Elijiah Porter | Nassau (NY) | D | Fr. | |
| Cayden Collins | Harford (MD) | SSDM | So. | |
| Mark Durling | Harford (MD) | FO | So. | |
| Austin Collins | CCBC Essex (MD) | LSM | Fr. | |
| Sam Barrett | Anne Arundel (MD) | M | So. | |
| Chris Evans | CCBC Essex (MD) | FO | So. | |