| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Gregory Elijah-Brown | Onondaga (NY) | A | So | |
| Kamryn Gill | Nassau (NY) | A | So | |
| Wyatt Antkiewicz | CCBC Essex (MD) | M | So | |
| Anahalihs Doxtator | Onondaga (NY) | A | So | |
| Brendan McCabe | Nassau (NY) | D | So | |
| Zane Dalpe | Howard (MD) | A | So | |
| Andrew Tittmann | Nassau (NY) | GK | So | |
| Dylan Tomarchio | Harford (MD) | A | So | |
| Christian LeFeurve | Genesee (NY) | A | Fr | |
| Brandon Grusholt | Anne Arundel (MD) | S | So | |
| Kollin Vaught | CCBC Essex (MD) | FO | So | |
| Trevor Sousa | Harford (MD) | M | So | |
| Alex Epple | Harford (MD) | GK | So | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Logan Lemelbaum | Onondaga (NY) | GK | So | |
| Brian Pohoreckyj | Nassau (NY) | A | So | |
| Connor Cecala | Onondaga (NY) | D | So | |
| Sean Gillespie | Nassau (NY) | D | So | |
| Sean Tierney | Onondaga (NY) | M | So | |
| Tyler Goode | Genesee (NY) | A | So | |
| Thomas Mai | Nassau (NY) | A / M | So | |
| John Pavlick | Howard (MD) | D | Fr | |
| Houston Horton | Nassau (NY) | FO | Fr | |
| Jack Mulligan | Harford (MD) | A | Fr | |
| Ethan Storey | Harford (MD) | D | So | |
| Douglas Fitzmaurice | CCBC Essex (MD) | D | So | |
| Carter Korzenski | Harford (MD) | A | So | |