All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Ice Hockey Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| Harrison Aide |
Dakota (ND) |
F | 5' 8" | 168 | Fr. | |
| Kenny Fitzgerald |
Dakota (ND) | G |
6' 2" | 175 | So. | |
| Cody Longie |
Dakota (ND) |
F |
6' 1" | 220 | So. | |
| Nial Mills |
Dakota (ND) |
F |
5' 11" | 181 |
So. | |
| Anthony Cybulski |
Erie (NY) | F | 5' 5" | 145 | Fr. | |
| Kyle Constanty |
Hudson Valley (NY) |
F | 5' 7" | 145 | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| Zach Garrett |
Dakota (ND) |
F |
6' 2" | 211 |
Fr. | |
| Michael Krause |
Erie (NY) |
D |
6' 0" | 155 | So. | |
| Alex Suchan |
Erie (NY) |
F | 6' 1" | 210 |
So. | |
| Adam Hosmer |
Hudson Valley (NY) |
D | 6' 4" | 200 |
So. | |
| Nate Muller |
Hudson Valley (NY) | G |
6' 0" | 170 |
So. | |
| Logan Warren |
Mohawk Valley (NY) |
D |
5' 9" | 170 | So. | |