All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division I Men's Basketball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | POS. | |
| Patrick Suemnick | Triton (IL) | Fr. | F | |
| Daniss Jenkins | Odessa (TX) | So. | G | |
| Mohamed Diarra | Garden City (KS) | So. | F | |
| AJ Cajuste | Indian River State (FL) | So. | PG | |
| Mohamed Wague | Harcum (PA) | Fr. | F | |
| J'Vonne Hadley | Indian Hills (IA) | So. | G | |
| Sincere Parker | Moberly Area (MO) | Fr. | G | |
| Jordan Brinson | Salt Lake (UT) | So. | G | |
| Sean East | John A. Logan (IL) | So. | G | |
| Deshawndre Washington | Northwest Florida State | So. | G | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | POS. | |
| Brian Moore | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | Fr. | CG | |
| Dantwan Grimes | Kilgore (TX) | So. | G | |
| Marvin McGhee | South Georgia Tech | So. | PG | |
| Themus Fulks | Dodge City (KS) | Fr. | G | |
| Drake Allen | Snow (UT) | Fr. | G | |
| Kieves Turner | South Plains (TX) | Fr. | G | |
| Love Bettis | Coffeyville (KS) | So. | G | |
| Quincy McGriff | Salt Lake (UT) | Fr. | G | |
| Kyron Gibson | Lee (TX) | So. | G | |
| Chris Pryor | McLennan (TX) | So. | G | |
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | POS. | |
| Yaxel Lendeborg | Arizona Western | Fr. | F | |
| Greg Gordon | Dyersburg State (TN) | Fr. | F | |
| Lue Williams | Coastal Alabama-Bay Minette | So. | G | |
| Zeke Cook | Northeast Mississippi | Fr. | F | |
| Jesiah West | Southeastern (IA) | So. | F | |
| Dayne Prim | Western Wyoming | So. | F | |
| Bradley Douglas | Santa Fe (FL) | Fr. | G | |
| Andres Burney | Shelton State (AL) | Fr. | F | |
| Tre Dinkins | Harcum (PA) | Fr. | G | |
| Angelo Stuart | Hutchinson (KS) | So. | G | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Josiah Shackleford | Brunswick (NC) | Fr. | C | |
| Jay Rodgers | Cochise (AZ) | Fr. | G | |
| German Plotnikov | North Platte (NE) | Fr. | G | |
| Melvin Council Jr. | Monroe College (NY) | So. | G | |
| Taj Anderson | Indian Hills (IA) | So. | G | |
| Jayvis Harvey | Georgia Highlands | So. | G | |
| Luke Davis | Southwestern Illinois | Fr. | F | |
| Fede Federiko | Northern Oklahoma-Tonkawa | Fr. | F | |
| Clarence Daniels | Lake Region State (ND) | So. | F | |
| Jakorie Smith | East Mississippi | So. | F | |
| Tommie Lewis | Polk State (FL) | So. | G | |
| Nae'qwan Tomlin | Chipola (FL) | So. | G | |
| Lamar Wilkerson | Three Rivers (MO) | Fr. | G | |
| Stephan Gabriel | Highland (IL) | So. | G/F | |
| AC Curry | Otero (WY) | So. | SF | |
| Brett Thompson | Mineral Area (MO) | So. | G | |
| Jordan Johnson | Allegany College of Maryland | So. | G | |
| Derrick Sinkler Jr. | USC Salkehatchie | So. | G | |
| Paul Otieno | Kilgore (TX) | So. | G | |
| John Buggs | Hill (TX) | Fr. | G | |
| Jaronn Wilkens | Pearl River (MS) | So. | F | |