All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division I Men's Basketball Committee.
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS |
| Dayjuan Anderson | Triton (IL) | G | Fr. |
| Issac Taveras | South Plains (TX) | G | So. |
| Marcus Whitlock Jr. | Cowley (KS) | G | Fr. |
| Isaiah Dorceus | Daytona State (FL) | G | So. |
| Abdoulaye Fall | Indian Hills (IA) | G/F | So. |
| Khoi Thurmon | Panola (TX) | G | So. |
| Isaac Finlinson | Snow (UT) | F | So. |
| LJ Hackman | Jones (MS) | G | So. |
| Lebron Thomas | Vincennes (IN) | G | So. |
| Cameron Williams | Trinity Valley (TX) | G/F | So. |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS |
| Seth Amunrud | Dawson (MT) | G | So. |
| Evan Chatman | McLennan (TX) | F | So. |
| Antonio Chol | Garden City (KS) | F | So. |
| Christian Harmon | Gulf Coast State (FL) | G/F | So. |
| Abdul Bashir | Casper (WY) | G | So. |
| Vaughn Weems | North Idaho | G | So. |
| Caleb Blackwell | South Plains (TX) | G | So. |
| Brent Moss | Barton (KS) | G | So. |
| Lateef Patrick | Trinidad State (CO) | G | So. |
| Ade Popoola | Moberly Area (MO) | G | So. |
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS |
| Edwin Suarez | Arizona Western | F | So. |
| Eric Mejia | Monroe University (NY) | G | Fr. |
| CJ Worshham | Panola (TX) | F | Fr. |
| Xavier Edmonds | Salt Lake (UT) | F | So. |
| Samuel Hincapie | Lake Land (IL) | G | So. |
| Matt Hampton | Three Rivers (MO) | G | Fr. |
| Cameron Wallace | Holmes (MS) | F | So. |
| Jeremiah Littlejohn | Western Oklahoma State | G | So. |
| Edwin Daniel | Connors State (OK) | F | So. |
| Kedar Bodie | Bishop State (AL) | G | So. |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICANS | |||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS |
| Kami Young | Wallace State (AL) | G | So. |
| Armari Carraway | Eastern Arizona | G | So. |
| Merquiche Lewis | Southeastern (IA) | G | So. |
| Taylor Groves | Volunteer State (TN) | G | Fr. |
| Devon Rainey | South Georgia State | G | So. |
| Mason Sword | Hagerstown (MD) | F | So. |
| CJ McPherson | USC Salkahatchie (NC) | G | So. |
| Dimitri Clerc | Pensacola State (FL) | C | So. |
| Anthony Isaac | Blinn (TX) | F | So. |
| Jason Kimbrough | Highland (IL) | G | So. |
| Rex Stirling | Williston State (ND) | F | So. |
| Walter Campbell | Roane State (TN) | F | So. |
| Keandre Kindell | Barton (KS) | G | So. |
| Buddy Hammer Jr. | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | F | So. |
| Devere Palmer Jr. | Monroe University (NY) | F | So. |
| Dane Christensen | Gillette (WY) | F | Fr. |
| William Beugre-Kassi | Indian Hills (IA) | G | So. |
| KJ Vasser | Moberly Area (MO) | G | So. |
| Davius Loury | John A. Logan (IL) | G | Fr. |
| AJ Dent | Itawamba (MS) | G/F | So. |