All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division III Volleyball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Chloey Myers | DuPage (IL) | OH | So. | |
| Ariel Austin | Dallas College-Brookhaven (TX) | OH | Fr. | |
| Keke Lawrence | Sandhills (NC) | MH | So. | |
| Ava Sholtis | Owens (OH) | OH | Fr. | |
| Kaelynn Kudis | MN North-Mesabi Range | MB | So. | |
| Morgan Jack | Butler County (PA) | S | So. | |
| Madelyn Avery | Fulton-Montgomery (NY) | OH | So. | |
| Chelsey Farris | Lorain County (OH) | MH | So. | |
| Alyssa Fountain | DuPage (IL) | OH | So. | |
| Brooke DeGroff | Finger Lakes (NY) | OH | Fr. | |
| Ayana Bomani | Northampton (PA) | MH | Fr. | |
| Maddie White | Owens (OH) | OH | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Olivia Witek | DuPage (IL) | MH | So. | |
| Megan Rinicker | Central Lakes-Brainerd (MN) | MH | So. | |
| Josanne Lewis | Borough of Manhattan (NY) | OH | Fr. | |
| Aslyn Pry | Butler County (PA) | MH | So. | |
| Simone Mortel | Century (MN) | MH | So. | |
| Kaia Strom | Minnesota State | S | So. | |
| Jadyn Ketner | Dallas College-Brookhaven (TX) | LB | Fr. | |
| Kiley Nihart | Rochester (MN) | LB | So. | |
| Leah Vitiello | Dutchess (NY) | OH | So. | |
| Olivia Sims | Raritan Valley (NJ) | MB | So. | |
| Emma Crandell | Century (MN) | OH | So. | |
| Kalaya Pierce | Dallas College-Cedar Valley (TX) | S | So. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Mackenzie Maass | Harrisburg Area (PA) | MB | Fr. | |
| Madison Capwell | CC of Rhode Island | OH | So. | |
| Meghan Johnson | Finger Lakes (NY) | OH | So. | |
| Lisanel Rodriguez | Monroe-Bronx (NY) | S | Fr. | |
| Bailee Alexander | Dallas College-Richland (TX) | OH/MB | So. | |
| Molly McKinnon | Erie (NY) | OH | Fr. | |