All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division III Women's Soccer Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| GK | Brianna Flores | Dallas College Brookhaven | FR | |
| D | Ellysia Germain | Onondaga Community College | SO | |
| D | Isabella Workman | Delta College | FR | |
| M | Kendall Jackson | Delta College | SO | |
| M | Ella Rejiba | North Country Community College | FR | |
| M | Anna Sabo | Delta College | SO | |
| M | Krista Panko | Mohawk Valley Community College | SO | |
| F | Gianna Antovoni | Dallas College Brookhaven | FR | |
| F | Harmony Russell | Onondaga Community College | SO | |
| F | Summer Nasatka | Rowan College of South Jersey-Cumberland | SO | |
| F | Victoria Hernandez | Dallas College Cedar Valley | SO | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| GK | Hannah Gaddor | North Country Community College | FR | |
| GK | Ryann Bannerman | Brookdale Community College | SO | |
| D | Hailee Manteiga | Community College of Rhode Island | SO | |
| D | Rory Hagen | Ocean County College | SO | |
| M | Lizbeth Rojo | Suffolk CC | FR | |
| M | Danna Katherin Munoz | Ocean County College | FR | |
| M | Sarah Nasatka | Rowan College South Jersey - Gloucester | SO | |
| M | Kate Carlson | Dallas College Brookhaven | FR | |
| F | Jalyssa Villafuerte | Joliet Junior College | SO | |
| F | Samantha Stokely | Jefferson Community College | FR | |
| F | Isabella Moore | Rowan College South Jersey - Gloucester | SO | |