All-America selections are made by the NJCAA DI Men's Soccer Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| F | Lucas Contante | Barton (KS) | So | |
| F | Ato Smith Jr. | Tyler (TX) | Fr | |
| F | Adrian Faus Cabero | Eastern Oklahoma State | So | |
| M | Omar Mora | Angelina (TX) | So | |
| M | Terry Makedika | Arizona Western | So | |
| M | Thiago Jose da Silva | Monroe College (NY) | So | |
| M | Sora Funakoshi | Cowley (KS) | So | |
| D | Khaya Gregory | Salt Lake (UT) | So | |
| D | Jake Shaked | Tyler (TX) | So | |
| D | Henrique Lobato | Monroe College (NY) | Fr | |
| GK | Alvaro Ramos | Monroe College (NY) | Fr | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| F | Daniele Verdirosi | Eastern Florida State | So | |
| F | David Garcia | Blinn (TX) | So | |
| F | William Mugisha | Utah State Eastern | So | |
| F | Lucas Peruzo | Murray State (OK) | So | |
| F | Gustavo Marques | Indian Hills (IA) | So | |
| M | Carlos Zambrano | Daytona State (FL) | So | |
| M | Timothy Mason | Iowa Western | So | |
| D | Thiago Apolinario | Cowley (KS) | Fr | |
| D | Henrique Cruz | Barton (KS) | So | |
| D | Carles Zomeno | Salt Lake (UT) | So | |
| GK | Harvey Sellers | Indian Hills (IA) | Fr | |
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| F | Harry Tremblez | Rose State (OK) | So | |
| F | Raul Cedillo | Lewis & Clark (IL) | Fr | |
| F | Mila Mzamane | USC-Union (SC) | Fr | |
| M | Jose Ignacio Astudillo Medina | Western Texas | So | |
| M | Yuto Hatayama | Casper (WY) | So | |
| M | Kaito Ueki | Angelina (TX) | So | |
| M | Carl Romberg | Montgomery (MD) | Fr | |
| D | Siddiq Lezzar | LSU-Eunice (LA) | So | |
| D | Kohta Yamanashi | Casper (WY) | So | |
| D | Ales Kohoutek | Indian Hills (IA) | Fr | |
| GK | Ben Williams | Salt Lake (UT) | So | |