All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division III Men's Basketball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Kevin Mateo | Brookdale (NJ) | G | So. | |
| Drew Gaston | DuPage (IL) | G | So. | |
| Kameron Givens | Rochester (MN) | G | So. | |
| Luis Reynoso | Northern Essex (MA) | F | Fr. | |
| Bryan Quiller | Sandhills (NC) | F | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Jordan Drain | Mohawk Valley (NY) | G | ||
| Darion Jones | Dallas-North Lake (TX) | G | So. | |
| Anthony Walters | Queensborough (NY) | F | Fr. | |
| Jahmere Glover | Union (NJ) | F | Fr. | |
| Michael Marable | Northampton (PA) | G | So. | |
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Kevaughn Price | Butler County (PA) | G | Fr. | |
| Keith Hoffman | Madison (WI) | F/C | So. | |
| Victor Potter Jr. | Dutchess (NY) | F | So. | |
| LeNijel Robinson | Sandhills (NC) | G | So. | |
| Nick Williams | Brookdale (NJ) | G | Fr. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Trevor Green | Hudson Valley (NY) | G | So. | |
| Ed Trahan | Dallas-Richland (TX) | F | So. | |
| Xavier Hill | Corning (NY) | G/F | So. | |
| Dwayne Reliford | Dallas-Eastfield (TX) | F | Fr. | |
| Matt Elliott | DuPage (IL) | F | So. | |