All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division II Men's Basketball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Lamar Lovelace | Niagara County (NY) | G/F | So. | |
| Nakyel Shelton | South Suburban (IL) | G | So. | |
| Tymer Jackson | Johnson County (KS) | G | So. | |
| Antewan Webber | Florida Gateway | G | Fr. | |
| Trey Deveaux | Central (NE) | F | So. | |
| Jeremiah Burke | Iowa Lakes | F | So. | |
| D'Quarion Cole | Henry Ford (MI) | G | So. | |
| Romeo Aquino | Orange County (NY) | G | So. | |
| Jaidon Lipscomb | Lakeland (OH) | G | So. | |
| Jay Alvarez | Sullivan County (NY) | G | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Jamar Brown | Phoenix (AZ) | G | So. | |
| Avery Huggins | Pitt (NC) | G | So. | |
| Andrew Mills | Howard (MD) | F | Fr. | |
| Jeremiah Talton | John Wood (IL) | G | Fr. | |
| Joey Niesman | Waubonsee (IL) | G | So. | |
| Noah King | Kirkwood (IA) | G | Fr. | |
| JayShaun Freeman | Chesapeake (MD) | G | So. | |
| Kendall Taylor | Danville Area (IL) | F | So. | |
| Jemel Jones | Olive-Harvey (IL) | G | Fr. | |
| D'Juan Seal | Henry Ford (MI) | G | So. | |
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Nakaveion White | National Park (AR) | G | Fr. | |
| Trace Williams | Moraine Valley (IL) | G | So. | |
| Eddie Davis | Raritan Valley (NJ) | G | So. | |
| Traivar Jackson | Pima (AZ) | F | So. | |
| Damontae Taylor | South Suburban (IL) | F | So. | |
| Jamauri Bryant | Fayetteville Tech (NC) | G | So. | |
| Shawn Fulcher | Ellsworth (IA) | G | Fr. | |
| Myles Johnson | Kalamazoo Valley (MI) | G | So. | |
| Mikale Stevenson | Milwaukee Area Tech (WI) | G | So. | |
| Aidan Rubio | Macomb (MI) | G | Fr. | |