All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division I Men's Basketball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | POS. | |
| Jason Edwards | Dodge City (KS) | Fr | G | |
| Melvin Council Jr. | Monroe College (NY) | So | G | |
| Isaiah Moses | Southern Idaho | So | G | |
| Tayton Conerway | Ranger (TX) | So | G | |
| Don McHenry | Indian Hills (IA) | So | G | |
| Jayshayne Woodard | Indian River State (FL) | Fr | G | |
| Curt Lewis | John A. Logan (IL) | So | G | |
| Tre'von Spiller | Moberly Area (MO) | So | F | |
| Alejandro Vasquez | Salt Lake (UT) | So | G | |
| Kasean Pryor | Northwest Florida State | So | F | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | POS. | |
| Dejour Reaves | Trinidad State (CO) | So | G | |
| Greg Gordon | Dyersburg State (TX) | So | F | |
| DaVeon Thomas | Kilgore (TX) | Fr | G | |
| Oscar Cluff | Cochise (AZ) | So | F | |
| Jamal West | Clarendon (TX) | So | F | |
| Yaxel Lendeborg | Arizona Western | So | F | |
| Buru Naivalurua | Garden City (KS) | Fr | F | |
| Jacob Crews | Daytona State (FL) | So | F | |
| Lorenzo "Trey" Fort | Howard (TX) | So | G | |
| Quimari Peterson | John A. Logan (IL) | So | G | |
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | POS. | |
| Marcus Hill | Southern Union (AL) | So | G | |
| Carlos Hart | South Georgia State | So | G | |
| Jordan Thompson | Northern Oklahoma-Enid | So | G | |
| Dylan Canoville | Copiah-Lincoln (MS) | Fr | F | |
| Brandon Muntu | Triton (IL) | So | G | |
| Julian Mackey | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | So | G | |
| Elijah Elliott | Blinn (TX) | So | G | |
| Enoch Kalambay | Indian Hills (IA) | So | G | |
| Aaron Franklin | Hutchinson (KS) | Fr | G/F | |
| Caleb Johnson | Vincennes (IN) | So | F | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Tekao Carpenter | Allegany College of Maryland | Fr | G | |
| Joe Mpoyo | Dawson (MT) | So | F | |
| Toyaz Solomon | Caldwell Tech (NC) | So | F | |
| Blessing Adesipe | Miles (MT) | So | F | |
| Braxton Williams | Coastal Alabama - South | So | G | |
| Jamison Epps | Casper (WY) | So | G | |
| Zyterious Wright | Gordon State (GA) | So | G | |
| Christian Terrell | Meridian (MS) | So | G | |
| Aiden Gair | Missouri State-West Plains | So | G | |
| Khouri Carvey | Brunswick (NC) | Fr | F/C | |
| Jaylen Searles | Southeastern (IA) | So | G/F | |
| Ramean Hinton | Highland (IL) | So | G | |
| Robert Whaley | Southern Idaho | So | F | |
| Michael Houge | Walters State (TN) | So | G/F | |
| Andres Burney | Eastern Florida State | So | F | |
| Xavier Glenn | Connors State (OK) | So | G | |
| Corey Camper Jr. | Tyler (TX) | So | G | |
| Jaheim Tanksley | Moberly Area (MO) | So | G | |
| Blake Butler | East Mississippi | So | G | |
| Jadrian Tracey | Florida SouthWestern | So | G | |