All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Football Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Hunter Dekkers | Iowa Western | So. | |||
| RB | Waymond Jordan Jr. | Hutchinson (KS) | So. | |||
| RB | D'muriun Perteet | Northwest Mississippi | So. | |||
| TE | Brec Long | Coffeyville (KS) | So. | |||
| WR | Fresh Walters | Iowa Western | Fr. | |||
| WR | Tim Burns | Navarro (TX) | So. | |||
| OL | Cameron Todd | Garden City (KS) | Fr. | |||
| OL | LaParka Langston | Northwest Mississippi | So. | |||
| OL | Julio Madero | Navarro (TX) | Fr. | |||
| OL | Tyler Brumfield | Snow (UT) | So. | |||
| OL | Chance Hollomon | Iowa Western | So. | |||
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Seven Cloud | Butler (KS) | Fr. | |||
| DL | Marshon Oxley | Hutchinson (KS) | So. | |||
| DL | Walt Gary | Iowa Western | So. | |||
| DL | A.J. Prim | Pearl River (MS) | So. | |||
| LB | Darion White | Tyler (TX) | So. | |||
| LB | Noah Flemmings | Trinity Valley (TX) | So. | |||
| LB | Jawarren Corbin | Iowa Central | So. | |||
| DB | Fredd Adams | Northwest Mississippi | So. | |||
| DB | Sam Brooks | Dodge City (KS) | So. | |||
| DB | Jaylon Webb | Kilgore (TX) | So. | |||
| DB | Lucas Struck | Iowa Western | Fr. | |||
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| K | Freddy Perez | Georgia Military | Fr. | |||
| P | Breck Chambers | Blinn (TX) | So. | |||
| RS | Da'Realyst Clark | Butler (KS) | So. | |||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Donnie Smith | Snow (UT) | So. | |||
| RB | Trey Hall | Mississippi Gulf Coast | So. | |||
| RB | Keenan Phillips | Georgia Military | Fr. | |||
| TE | Karl Peterson | New Mexico Military | So. | |||
| WR | JP Coulter | Mississippi Gulf Coast | So. | |||
| WR | Reggie Frishknecht | Snow (UT) | Fr. | |||
| OL | Jonathan Ashley | Georgia Military | So. | |||
| OL | Daniel Hernandez | Trinity Valley (TX) | So. | |||
| OL | Kaliem Crowell | Garden City (KS) | So. | |||
| OL | Joseph Kallies | Iowa Central | So. | |||
| OL | Christian Bundra | Lackawanna (PA) | So. | |||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Solomone Langi | Snow (UT) | So. | |||
| DL | Aiden Benton | Georgia Military | Fr. | |||
| DL | Justin Garza | Blinn (TX) | So. | |||
| DL | Tavion Atkinson | Trinity Valley (TX) | Fr. | |||
| LB | Jarris Coney | Georgia Military | Fr. | |||
| LB | Williams Cornelson | Tyler (TX) | So. | |||
| LB | Donnie Smith | East Central (MS) | So. | |||
| DB | Titan Saxton | Snow (UT) | Fr. | |||
| DB | BJ Inmon | Snow (UT) | So. | |||
| DB | Stilton McKelvey | New Mexico Military | So. | |||
| DB | Armoni Rue | Highland (KS) | So. | |||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| K | Keegan Hughes | Lackawanna (PA) | So. | |||
| P | Jonah Dupont | Iowa Western | Fr. | |||
| LS | Aron Reinhardt | Lackawanna (PA) | So. | |||
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Samari Collier | Hutchinson (KS) | So. | |||
| QB | Chip Cooper | Georgia Military | So. | |||
| QB | Landon Vessel | Cisco (TX) | Fr. | |||
| RB | Cynir Bowers | Iowa Central | Fr. | |||
| RB | DeJuan Lacy | Garden City (KS) | Fr. | |||
| RB | Clay Thevenin | Navarro (TX) | Fr. | |||
| WR | Dariyonne Bryant | Highland (KS) | So. | |||
| OL | Bubba Craig | Hutchinson (KS) | Fr. | |||
| OL | Omarion Davis | Iowa Western | So. | |||
| OL | Saquan Miles | Hinds (MS) | So. | |||
| OL | Eric Aschenbeck | Blinn (TX) | So. | |||
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Jayden Madkins | Tyler (TX) | So. | |||
| DL | Howard Brown | Iowa Central | So. | |||
| DL | D.J. Burgess | Northwest Mississippi | So. | |||
| DL | Jeremiah Young | Independence (KS) | Fr. | |||
| LB | Landon Boss | Butler (KS) | So. | |||
| LB | Andrew Marshall | Lackawanna (PA) | Fr. | |||
| LB | Mataira Brown | Snow (UT) | Fr. | |||
| LB | JaQuel Mack | Hutchinson (KS) | Fr. | |||
| DB | Jakyri Jones | Georgia Military | So. | |||
| DB | Dylan Rowsey | Itawamba (MS) | So. | |||
| DB | Jayden Lawton | Tyler (TX) | So. | |||
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| K | Max Bartachek | Iowa Western | So. | |||
| RS | Shandon King | Snow (UT) | So. | |||
| RS | Nigel Cheeks | Ellsworth (IA) | So. | |||