All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Football Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Byron Jarrett | Iowa Central | So. | |||
| RB | Anthony Grant | New Mexico Military | So. | |||
| RB | La'Damian Webb | Jones (MS) | So. | |||
| WR | D. T. Sheffield | Northwest Mississippi | Fr. | |||
| WR | Malik Benson | Hutchinson (KS) | Fr. | |||
| TE | Deontay Campbell | Highland (KS) | So. | |||
| OL | Tyrone Webber | New Mexico Military | So. | |||
| OL | Maximus McCree | Iowa Central | Fr. | |||
| OL | Zackery Mendoza | Snow (UT) | So. | |||
| OL | Isaiah Adams | Garden City (KS) | So. | |||
| OL | Jaqavius Yates | Jones (MS) | So. | |||
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Maurice Westmoreland | Kilgore (TX) | So. | |||
| DL | Jeffrey M'ba | Independence (KS) | Fr. | |||
| DL | Quientrail Travis | Iowa Western | Fr. | |||
| DL | Seleti Fevaleaki | Snow (UT) | So. | |||
| LB | Xavier Benson | Tyler (TX) | So. | |||
| LB | Jacob Ellis | Iowa Western | Fr. | |||
| LB | Mike Smith | Mississippi Gulf Coast | So. | |||
| DB | Keionte Scott | Snow (UT) | Fr. | |||
| DB | Keylon Kennedy | Garden City (KS) | So. | |||
| DB | Namdi Obiazor | Iowa Western | Fr. | |||
| DB | Desmond Williams | East Central (MS) | So. | |||
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| K | Matthew O'Brien | Tyler (TX) | Fr. | |||
| P | Corry Wilhoit | Dodge City (KS) | Fr. | |||
| RS | Taylor Larsen | Snow (UT) | Fr. | |||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Barry Brown | Lackawanna (PA) | Fr. | |||
| RB | Anwar Lewis | Hutchinson (KS) | Fr. | |||
| RB | Targhee Lambson | Snow (UT) | Fr. | |||
| WR | Delvin Palmer | Lackawanna (PA) | So. | |||
| WR | Jeremiah Aaron | Navarro (TX) | So. | |||
| TE | Logan Compton | New Mexico Military | So. | |||
| OL | Joseph Taase | New Mexico Military | Fr. | |||
| OL | Stevie Young | Hutchinson (KS) | So. | |||
| OL | Kadeem Willis | Monroe (NY) | Fr. | |||
| OL | Reggie Young | Iowa Central | So. | |||
| OL | Lisala Tai | Snow (UT) | Fr. | |||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Kamaurja Kenney | Trinity Valley (TX) | So. | |||
| DL | Douglas Blue-Eli | Monroe (NY) | Fr. | |||
| DL | Tristin Waugh | Iowa Central | So. | |||
| DL | Cortez Hogans | Snow (UT) | So. | |||
| LB | Reise Collier | Coffeyville (KS) | Fr. | |||
| LB | Zharell Walker | Monroe (NY) | So. | |||
| LB | Kohl Hogan | Snow (UT) | Fr. | |||
| DB | Kobe Savage | Tyler (TX) | So. | |||
| DB | Major Williams | Iowa Central | Fr. | |||
| DB | Marquise Gilbert | Hutchinson (KS) | Fr. | |||
| DB | Moses Alexander | Kilgore (TX) | So. | |||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| K | Noah Sauberan | Iowa Western | Fr. | |||
| P | Kaleb Cue | Cisco (TX) | Fr. | |||
| RS | Cohen Russell | Lackawanna (PA) | So. | |||
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Qua Gray | Navarro (TX) | So. | |||
| QB | Dylan Laible | Hutchinson (KS) | So. | |||
| RB | Joshua Berry | Blinn (TX) | Fr. | |||
| RB | Daylen Boddie | Iowa Central | Fr. | |||
| WR | Darius Lassiter | Butler (KS) | So. | |||
| WR | Desna Washington | Iowa Central | Fr. | |||
| WR | Ryan Flournoy | Iowa Western | Fr. | |||
| TE | Tevita Noa | Snow (UT) | So. | |||
| OL | Wallace Unamba | Kilgore (TX) | So. | |||
| OL | Terrance McClain | Coffeyville (KS) | So. | |||
| OL | Landon Nelson | Iowa Western | Fr. | |||
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Warren Peeples | Highland (KS) | So. | |||
| DL | Bryton Thompson | Blinn (TX) | So. | |||
| DL | Jackson Filer | Iowa Western | Fr. | |||
| DL | Nadame Tucker | Hutchinson (KS) | So. | |||
| LB | Keith Harris | Kilgore (TX) | So. | |||
| LB | Jalen Angelle | Highland (KS) | So. | |||
| LB | Izayah Aekins | Hocking (OH) | ||||
| DB | Owen Fa'amoe | Snow (UT) | So. | |||
| DB | Zahquan Frazier | Coffeyville (KS) | Fr. | |||
| DB | CJ Christian | Iowa Central | Fr. | |||
| DB | Diontrel Wommack | Iowa Western | So. | |||
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| P | Ty Nissen | Iowa Western | Fr. | |||
| P | Brodie Taylor | Snow (UT) | So. | |||
| RS | Kaden Wetjen | Iowa Western | Fr. | |||