All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division III Men's Basketball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | HT. | CLASS | |
| Chris Buckley | Central Lakes (MN) | G | 6-0 | So. | |
| Jamaurie Coakley | Bunker Hill (MA) | G | 6-2 | So. | |
| Derrick Felder | Herkimer (NY) | G | 5-11 | So. | |
| Steven Tynes | Suffolk County (NY) | G | 5-9 | So. | |
| Caleb Williams | Richland (TX) | G | 6-2 | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | HT. | CLASS | |
| Rashaun Coleman | Eastfield (TX) | G | 5-11 | So. | |
| Jay Davis | Northamtpon (PA) | G | 6-3 | So. | |
| Alex Morales | Prince George's (MD) | G | 6-7 | So. | |
| Christian Simmons | Corning (NY) | F | 6-2 | So. | |
| Letrell West | Middlesex County (NJ) | G | 6-3 | Fr. | |
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | HT. | CLASS | |
| Adam Anhold | Madison (WI) | F | 6-8 | Fr. | |
| Quran Dublin | Borough of Manhattan (NY) | G | 6-1 | So. | |
| Nana Kodom-Ayensu | Rock Valley (IL) | F | 6-6 | So. | |
| Azende Johnson | Hocking (OH) | G | 6-2 | Fr. | |
| Jackson Reid | Central Carolina (NC) | G | 6-4 | Fr. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | HT. | CLASS | |
| Justin Castro | Anoka-Ramsey (MN) | G | 5-10 | So. | |
| John Halaby, Jr. | Oxford Emory (GA) | G | 6-0 | Fr. | |
| Marcus McCarty | Bristol (MA) | G | 6-1 | So. | |
| Cheyenne Nettleton | Nassau (NY) | G | 5-9 | So. | |
| Ja'Zere Noel | Rowan-Gloucester (NJ) | F | 6-5 | Fr. | |