All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division I Softball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| P | Rayna Cruickshanks | Odessa (TX) | SO | |
| P | Britney Lewinski | Seminole State (OK) | SO | |
| P | Belle Sardja | Florida SouthWestern | SO | |
| P | Tori Coffman | Walters State (TN) | FR | |
| C | Lyndsey Madrigal | Salt Lake (UT) | SO | |
| INF | Georgia Hood | Pensacola State (FL) | SO | |
| INF | Destiny Lewis | Indian Hills (IA) | SO | |
| INF | Ayva McComas | Northeastern (CO) | FR | |
| INF | Savannah Clausen | Eastern Arizona | SO | |
| INF | Gracie Tentinger | Southern Idaho | SO | |
| OF | Amiah Galcatcher | Grayson (TX) | SO | |
| OF | Caydra Parker | Chattanooga State (TN) | FR | |
| OF | Gianna Guerriero | Central Florida | SO | |
| OF | Brantleigh Parrott | Gaston (NC) | FR | |
| UTL | Tinley Schmidgall | Arizona Western | SO | |
| DP | Shaylann Grace | Temple (TX) | SO | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| P | Jaileen Mancha | Eastern Arizona | SO | |
| P | Allyson Montgomery | Butler (KS) | SO | |
| P | Sami Huck | Jefferson (MO) | FR | |
| P | Alina Varga | Indian River State (FL) | SO | |
| C | Kenna Collett | Grayson (TX) | SO | |
| INF | Arriana Wright | San Jacinto-South (TX) | FR | |
| INF | Mckenna Johnson | Seminole State (OK) | SO | |
| INF | Kasey Bennett | Walters State (TN) | SO | |
| INF | Brooke Roberts | Central Florida | SO | |
| INF | Clarisa Zapata | Odessa (TX) | SO | |
| OF | Elise Munoz | Pima (AZ) | SO | |
| OF | Carsyn Cox | Grayson (TX) | SO | |
| OF | Sydney McCray | Florida SouthWestern | FR | |
| OF | Cynthia Sizemore | Navarro (TX) | SO | |
| UTL | Julia Kwakernaak | Indian Hills (IA) | FR | |
| DP | AJ Agers | Three Rivers (MO) | FR | |
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| P | Karlie McKenzie | Kaskaskia (IL) | FR | |
| P | Madie Anderson | Indian Hills (IA) | SO | |
| P | Gracie Walters | Southern Idaho | SO | |
| P | Jordyn Ages | Grayson (TX) | SO | |
| C | Eva Richardson | Lake Land (IL) | SO | |
| INF | Aspen Goetz | Hutchinson (KS) | SO | |
| INF | Kennan Nunamaker | Temple (TX) | FR | |
| INF | Avery Mercer | Georgia Military | SO | |
| INF | Sierrah Snook | St. Petersburg (FL) | SO | |
| INF | Lauren De La Cruz | Midland (TX) | SO | |
| OF | Kyra McIntosh | Metropolitan (MO) | SO | |
| OF | Mya Jack | Monroe College (NY) | SO | |
| OF | Sydney Harris | Volunteer State (TN) | SO | |
| OF | Emma Green | Rose State (OK) | SO | |
| UTL | Braleigh King | Eastern Oklahoma State | FR | |
| DP | Jordyn De Los Santos | Tyler (TX) | FR | |