All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division II Men's Basketball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Ahamadou Fofana | Erie (NY) | G | So. | |
| Justin Brookens | Iowa Lakes | G | So. | |
| Jacob Falko | Cecil (MD) | G | So. | |
| Darius Lee | Sullivan County (NY) | G | So. | |
| Xavier Fuller | Scottsdale (AZ) | G | So. | |
| Jamarius Hairston | Davidson County (NC) | G | So. | |
| Marty Jackson | North Central Missouri | F | So. | |
| Courtney Carter | South Suburban (IL) | G | So. | |
| Jared Johnson | Prairie State (IL) | F | Fr. | |
| Taylor Currie | Mott (MI) | C | Fr. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| JaQuaylon Mays | Johnson County (KS) | G | So. | |
| Sheldon Stevens | Southern Arkansas University Tech | G | So. | |
| Chandler Bevans | John Wood (IL) | F | So. | |
| Lorenzo Smith | Dakota County Technical (MN) | G | So. | |
| Vejas Grazulis | Muskegon (MI) | C | Fr. | |
| Tyreke Johnson | Lakeland (OH) | G | So. | |
| Yuri Swinford | Milwaukee Area Tech (WI) | F | So. | |
| Isaiah Jennings | Montgomery (MD) | G | So. | |
| Luke Appel | Kirkwood (IA) | F | So. | |
| Leon Ayers | Henry Ford (MI) | G | So. | |
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Roman Behrens | Central (NE) | G | So. | |
| Rick'Keem Mixson | Raritan Valley (NJ) | G | So. | |
| Atavian Butler | North Central Missouri | G | Fr. | |
| Kendall Robinson | Sullivan County (NY) | F | So. | |
| Jalen Lynn | Arkansas State Mid-South | G | So. | |
| Jake Lieppert | Pima (AZ) | G | Fr. | |
| Cecelio Montgomery | United Tribes Tech (ND) | G | Fr. | |
| Justus Baldwin | Wake Tech (NC) | G | So. | |
| Joshua Morris | Morris (NJ) | F | So. | |
| Kylan Shipp | Muskegon (MI) | G | So. | |