All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Football Committee
| FIRST-TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Peyton O'Laughlin | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| RB | Jaden McGill | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| RB | Roosevelt Cage | North Dakota SCS | So. | |||
| WR | Trevion Carothers | North Dakota SCS | Fr. | |||
| WR | Rayshion Bien-Aise | Nassau (NY) | So. | |||
| WR | Terrence Isaac Jr. | Rochester (MN) | So. | |||
| OL | Gavin Layton | Rochester (MN) | So. | |||
| OL | Alejandro Arellano | DuPage (IL) | Fr. | |||
| OL | Damaurius Stewart | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| OL | Dawson Hageman | North Dakota SCS | So. | |||
| OL | Ethan Bonacchi | Nassau (NY) | So. | |||
| FIRST-TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Jason Gwan | Erie (NY) | Fr. | |||
| DL | Teyel Lowe | Minnesota West | So. | |||
| DL | Seth Thomas | Rochester (MN) | So. | |||
| DL | Bobby Anderson | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| LB | Shamarr Joppy | Hudson Valley (NY) | So. | |||
| LB | Martell Williams | Rochester (MN) | So. | |||
| LB | Kellon King | DuPage (IL) | Fr. | |||
| DB | Brandon Perry | Louisburg (NC) | Fr. | |||
| DB | Riley Dravet | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| DB | Guy Goss | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| DB | Alex Briggs | MN North-Vermillion | So. | |||
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| K | Christian Casillas | DuPage (IL) | Fr. | |||
| P | Thomas Dellaporta | Nassau (NY) | So. | |||
| RS | Quonterrion Brooks | Minnesota West | Fr. | |||
| SECOND-TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| QB | Johnathan Mosley | MN North-Mesabi Range | So. | |||
| RB | David Collins | Central Lakes-Brainerd (MN) | So. | |||
| RB | Christian Franklin | Louisburg (NC) | So. | |||
| WR | Fabian Baez | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| WR | Trent Johnson | Erie (NY) | So. | |||
| WR | Jaylin Weathers | Erie (NY) | So. | |||
| OL | Quentin Butler | Louisburg (NC) | Fr. | |||
| OL | Tyshown Ray | Louisburg (NC) | So. | |||
| OL | Dennis Lutchoomun | MN North-Mesabi Range | Fr. | |||
| OL | Jarvis Green | Minnesota State | So. | |||
| OL | Austin Boesch | Central Lakes-Brainerd (MN) | Fr. | |||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| DL | Xzavier Fields | Louisburg (NC) | So. | |||
| DL | Anthony Schettino | Nassau (NY) | So. | |||
| DL | Sean King | Hudson Valley (NY) | So. | |||
| DL | Keondre Hodges | Minnesota State | So. | |||
| LB | Abubakarr Kargbo | Nassau (NY) | So. | |||
| LB | Eric Lumpkin | North Dakota SCS | So. | |||
| LB | Lovely Tshibanda | MN North Mesabi Range | So. | |||
| DB | Shamilyn Joppy | Hudson Valley (NY) | So. | |||
| DB | Damon Ennett | Nassau (NY) | Fr. | |||
| DB | Andrew Ewald | DuPage (IL) | Fr. | |||
| DB | Darrick Baartman | Minnesota West | So. | |||
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | NAME | COLLEGE | CLASS | |||
| K | Rodrigo Castaneda | Rochester (MN) | So. | |||
| P | Mason Wojtas | DuPage (IL) | So. | |||
| RS | Joshua Peguero | Hudson Valley (NY) | Fr. | |||