All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division III Volleyball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Kayla Bekier | Owens (OH) | OH | So. | |
| Sydney Berg | Central Lakes (MN) | OH | So. | |
| Jenna Caskey | Jamestown (NY) | OH | So. | |
| Bobby Diamond | Columbus State (OH) | OH | So. | |
| Morgan Frisby | Brookhaven (TX) | S | So. | |
| Audrey Jenkins | Columbus State (OH) | S | So. | |
| Rachel Kandefer | Harper (IL) | MB | Fr. | |
| Brekkin McCready | Rochester (MN) | S | So. | |
| Lorena Perez | Richland (TX) | OH | So. | |
| Carrie Rutledge | Rochester (MN) | OH | So. | |
| Tyriana Settles | Owens (OH) | OH | Fr. | |
| Hailey Tihlarik | Central Lakes (MN) | L | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Stephanie Berdon | Fashion IT (NY) | S/Opp. | So. | |
| Hannah Chiswick | Raritan Valley (NJ) | OH | Fr. | |
| Cathleen Flannery | Madison (WI) | OH | So. | |
| Madison Hand | North Lake (TX) | OH | So. | |
| Sydney Hovland | Minnesota State | S | So. | |
| Paige Hughes | Queensborough (NY) | OH | So. | |
| Brianna Kosinski | SUNY Broome (NY) | S | So. | |
| Yasmin Miller | Brookhaven (TX) | OH | Fr. | |
| Kara Starr | Harrisburg Area (PA) | OH/L | So. | |
| Marjorie Vazquez | Jefferson (NY) | OH | So. | |
| Sydney Williams | Eastfield (TX) | MB | So. | |
| Laurissa Zavala | Brookhaven (TX) | MB | So. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | CLASS | |
| Montana Baker | Mesabi Range (MN) | OH | So. | |
| Jenna Butler | Fashion IT (NY) | L | So. | |
| Kara Cisweski | Rock Valley (IL) | MB | So. | |
| Abigail Cmar | CC of Allegheny County (PA) | OH | Fr. | |
| Carley Modlin | Sandhills (NC) | MB | Fr. | |
| Kara Sullinger | Lorain County (OH) | S | So. | |