All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division III Softball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| P | Breanna Crown | Rock Valley (IL) | Fr. | |
| P | Brooke Harder | North Dakota SCS | Fr. | |
| P | Kali Puppolo | Herkimer (NY) | Fr. | |
| INF | Paige Eckert | Brookdale (NJ) | So. | |
| INF | Talyn McClafin | Itasca (MN) | Fr. | |
| INF | Madason Shaw | Rock Valley (IL) | So. | |
| OF | Lydia Danner | Lehigh Carbon (PA) | So. | |
| OF | Michele DiNicola | Corning (NY) | Fr. | |
| OF | Sarah Goff | Joliet (IL) | So. | |
| DP | Keeanna Wolcik | Herkimer (NY) | So. | |
| UT | Courtney Fernette | Rock Valley (IL) | Fr. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| P | Bailey Pedersen | Lehigh Carbon (PA) | So. | |
| P | Amber Terlaje | Monroe (NY) | So. | |
| C | Nicole Sheffer | Onondaga (NY) | So. | |
| INF | Kayla Christopherson | Itasca (MN) | So. | |
| INF | Maria Marcera | Monroe (NY) | Fr. | |
| INF | Shannon Moore | Herkimer (NY) | So. | |
| OF | Nicolette Gentile | Rowan-Gloucester (NJ) | So. | |
| OF | Katrina Hand | Brookdale (NJ) | So. | |
| OF | Jennah Hogan | Herkimer (NY) | Fr. | |
| DP | Mackenzie Guzy | Lehigh Carbon (PA) | Fr. | |
| UT | Carly Kjersgaard | Middlesex County (NJ) | So. | |