All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division III Men's Soccer Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| GK | Pablo Cubas | Richland (TX) | Fr. | |
| D | Marius Svendsen | Herkimer (NY) | So. | |
| D | Mariano Fazio | Richland (TX) | Fr. | |
| D | Pantelis Konomis | Nassau (NY) | Fr. | |
| MF | Juan Alava | Nassau (NY) | Fr. | |
| MF | Lucio Martinez | Richland (TX) | So. | |
| MF | Sam Hall | Genesee (NY) | So. | |
| F | Rodrigo Albuquerque | Genesee (NY) | Fr. | |
| F | Mohamed Essay | Richland (TX) | So. | |
| F | Jean Paul Rodriguez | Nassau (NY) | Fr. | |
| F | Lautaro Berisso | Camden County (NJ) | Fr. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | CLASS | |
| GK | Guilherme Griza | Westchester (NY) | Fr. | |
| D | Ebrima Jatta | Schoolcraft (MI) | So. | |
| D | Bryce Waller | Howard (MD) | So. | |
| MF | Kent Meier | Cayuga (NY) | Fr. | |
| MF | Michael Szaflarski | Triton (IL) | Fr. | |
| MF | Alex Dalou | Schoolcraft (MI) | Fr. | |
| MF | Daouda Coulibaly | Borough of Manhattan (NY) | So. | |
| F | Spencer Urquiza | Cayuga (NY) | So. | |
| F | Gabriel Monaighan | Anoka-Ramsey (MN) | Fr. | |
| F | Hadi Raoofi | Brookdale (NJ) | Fr. | |
| F | Walter Valera | Bunker Hill (MA) | Fr. | |