All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Division II Men's Basketball Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | HT. | CLASS | |
| Noble Fahnbulleh | Dakota County Tech (MN) |
G | 6' 3" | So. | |
| Danzel Wright | Johnson County (KS) |
G | 6' 0" | So. | |
| Hunter Rhodes | Kirkwood (IA) |
G | 6' 0" | So. | |
| Javon Haines | Lansing (MI) |
G | 6' 3" | So. | |
| CJ Hill | Louisburg (NC) |
G | 6' 1" | So. | |
| DeShawndre Black | Schoolcraft (MI) |
G | 6' 2" | So. | |
| Reshardd Harris | Sinclair (OH) |
F | 6' 4" | So. | |
| Connor MacDougall | South Mountain (AZ) |
C | 6' 10" | So. | |
| Jovan Mooring | South Suburban (IL) |
G | 6' 2" | So. | |
| Eric Gillespie | Triton (IL) |
G | 5' 10" | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | HT. | CLASS | |
| Greg Heckstall | Bryant & Stratton (VA) |
G | 6' 7" | Fr. | |
| Shawn Shelton | Dean (MA) |
F | 6' 6" | So. | |
| Brett Rau | Elgin (IL) |
G | 6' 3" | So. | |
| Yusuf Yakubu | Erie (NY) |
F | 6' 8" | So. | |
| Chris Jones | Iowa Lakes | G | 6' 0" | So. | |
| Eddie Longmeyer | Lincoln Land (IL) |
G | 6' 2" | So. | |
| Eddie Tornes | Muskegon (MI) |
G | 6' 2" | So. | |
| Terrance Bush | North Central Missouri | G | 6' 2" | So. | |
| James Richardson | Raritan Valley (NJ) |
G | 6' 0" | So. | |
| Snyder Cenecharles | Southeast (NE) |
G | 6' 3" | So. | |
| THIRD TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
| PLAYER | COLLEGE | POS. | HT. | CLASS | |
| Rze Culbreath | Garrett (MD) |
G | 6' 0" | So. | |
| Tarae Potter | Jackson (MI) |
G | 6' 5" | Fr. | |
| Samuel Joseph | Jamestown (NY) |
G | 6' 2" | Fr. | |
| Chris Scott | Lakeland (OH) | F | 6' 8" | So. | |
| Jamarcus Hairston | Louisburg (NC) |
F | 6' 7" | So. | |
| Thomas Farrior, Jr. | Manor (PA) |
G | 6' 1" | So. | |
| Jalen Olds | North Arkansas | F | 6' 5" | Fr. | |
| Tyvon Cooper | Orange County (NY) |
G | 6' 0" | So. | |
| Terrence Johnson | South Mountain (AZ) |
G | 6' 4" | Fr. | |
| Terrance Smith | Southwestern (IA) |
F | 6' 7" | So. | |