All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Football Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| QB | Parker McNeil | Navarro (TX) | 6-4 | 223 | So. | |
| RB | Brock Sturges | Butler (KS) | 5-10 | 210 | Fr. | |
| RB | ZaQuandre White | Iowa Western | 6-2 | 214 | So. | |
| WR | Jason Brownlee | East Mississippi | 6-3 | 190 | So. | |
| WR | Torenio Davis | Georgia Military | 6-4 | 195 | So. | |
| TE | Sameer Parks | Lackawanna (PA) | 6-2 | 220 | So. | |
| OL | Jeremy Flax | Independence (KS) | 6-6 | 320 | Fr. | |
| OL | Ashton Gist | Northwest Mississippi | 6-1 | 285 | So. | |
| OL | Steven Hubbard | Kilgore (TX) | 6-3 | 335 | So. | |
| OL | Trevor Reid | Georgia Military | 6-3 | 301 | So. | |
| OL | Richard Rodriguez | Iowa Central | 6-5 | 320 | Fr. | |
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| DL | Latrell Bankston | Hutchinson (KS) | 6-1 | 299 | So. | |
| DL | Yaya Diaby | Georgia Military | 6-4 | 256 | So. | |
| DL | Devin Drew | Iowa Western | 6-3 | 280 | So. | |
| DL | Sedrick Williams | Kilgore (TX) | 6-2 | 305 | So. | |
| LB | Da'Quan Cross | Iowa Central | 6-5 | 200 | So. | |
| LB | Race Moser | Trinity Valley (TX) | 6-0 | 207 | So. | |
| LB | Keshun Parker | Itawamba (MS) | 5-11 | 225 | So. | |
| DB | Ji'Ayir Brown | Lackawanna (PA) | 6-1 | 205 | So. | |
| DB | Marcus Haskins | Iowa Western | 6-1 | 185 | So. | |
| DB | Jackie Matthews | Mississippi Gulf Coast | 6-0 | 195 | So. | |
| DB | Ronald Williams | Hutchinson (KS) | 6-2 | 188 | So. | |
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| K | Eddie Godina | Trinity Valley (TX) | 5-11 | 172 | So. | |
| P | Robens Beauplan | East Central (MS) | 6-0 | 209 | Fr. | |
| RS | Delvin Palmer | Lackawanna (PA) | 5-9 | 160 | Fr. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| QB | Chance Lovertich | Mississippi Gulf Coast | 5-11 | 200 | So. | |
| RB | Greg Garner | Cisco (TX) | 6-0 | 225 | So. | |
| RB | Ladamian Webb | Jones (MS) | 5-8 | 190 | Fr. | |
| WR | Daquan Bailey-Brown | Dodge City (KS) | 5-9 | 170 | So. | |
| WR | Omar Manning | Kilgore (TX) | 6-3 | 224 | So. | |
| TE | Jacob Kainer | Tyler (TX) | 6-4 | 240 | So. | |
| OL | Egan Atkins | ASA Brooklyn (NY) | 6-3 | 315 | So. | |
| OL | TyKeem Doss | East Central (MS) | 6-5 | 348 | So. | |
| OL | Jacob Gamble | Iowa Western | 6-7 | 310 | So. | |
| OL | Makai Hart | Trinity Valley (TX) | 6-4 | 290 | So. | |
| OL | Jazston Turnetine | Hutchinson (KS) | 6-6 | 338 | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| DL | Terrence Cherry | East Mississippi | 6-2 | 250 | So. | |
| DL | Kirmari Gainous | Hutchinson (KS) | 6-3 | 255 | So. | |
| DL | Robert Hentz II | Northwest Mississippi | 6-0 | 270 | So. | |
| DL | Durrell Johnson | ASA Brooklyn (NY) | 6-4 | 225 | So. | |
| LB | Daylen Gill | Jones (MS) | 6-0 | 230 | So. | |
| LB | KeShaun Moore | Lackawanna (PA) | 6-1 | 250 | So. | |
| LB | Krishon Merriweather | Garden City (KS) | 6-0 | 220 | So. | |
| DB | John Blunt | Cisco (TX) | 6-2 | 190 | Fr. | |
| DB | Eugene Brown | Iowa Central | 6-0 | 203 | So. | |
| DB | Brian George | Highland (KS) | 6-1 | 189 | So. | |
| DB | CJ Thompson | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | 6-2 | 200 | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| K | Chase Contrerez | Iowa Western | 6-1 | 178 | So. | |
| P | Ryan Harwell | Tyler (TX) | 6-1 | 190 | So. | |
| RS | Rashad Witty | Iowa Central | 5-9 | 175 | So. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| QB | Demarcus Irons | Iowa Central | 6-5 | 200 | Fr. | |
| RB | Desean Phillips | North Dakota SCS | 5-11 | 205 | Fr. | |
| WR | Tanarous Achan | Iowa Central | 5-8 | 170 | So. | |
| WR | Norval Black | Lackawanna (PA) | 6-1 | 180 | So. | |
| WR | Antwan Downs | Itasca (MN) | 6-3 | 208 | Fr. | |
| WR | Kaedin Robinson | ASA Brooklyn (NY) | 6-2 | 195 | Fr. | |
| OL | Jordan Chapman | Jones (MS) | 6-3 | 270 | So. | |
| OL | Caden Coulson | Ellsworth (IA) | 6-2 | 280 | Fr. | |
| OL | Tre'Quan Dorsey | Lackawanna (PA) | 6-3 | 280 | So. | |
| OL | Nymonta Doucoure | Garden City (KS) | 6-4 | 350 | So. | |
| OL | Sidney Walker | Kilgore (TX) | 6-3 | 275 | So. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| DL | Ranadree Bradley | Itasca (MN) | 6-5 | 241 | So. | |
| DL | Ali Gaye | Garden City (KS) | 6-6 | 280 | So. | |
| DL | Kelton Moss | Kilgore (TX) | 6-2 | 295 | So. | |
| DL | Jacob Poetzl | Ellsworth (IA) | 6-4 | 245 | Fr. | |
| DL | Dominic Quewon | Iowa Western | 6-3 | 245 | So. | |
| DL | Greg Rose | Lackawanna (PA) | 6-3 | 255 | So. | |
| LB | Averie Habas | Iowa Western | 6-3 | 225 | Fr. | |
| LB | Chris Sanders | Tyler (TX) | 6-2 | 240 | So. | |
| LB | Cameron Strapp | Itasca (MN) | 6-0 | 200 | So. | |
| DB | Nathan Steward | North Dakota SCS | 6-0 | 170 | So. | |
| DB | DeJahn Warren | Lackawanna (PA) | 6-0 | 175 | Fr. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| K | Andres Dos Santos Aires | Garden City (KS) | 6-5 | 210 | Fr. | |
| RS | Manny Jones | Jones (MS) | 5-5 | 165 | So. | |
| RS | Fred Jackson | New Mexico Military | 5-9 | 185 | So. | |