All-America selections are made by the NJCAA Football Committee
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| QB | Parker McNeil | Navarro (TX) | 6-4 | 215 | Fr. | |
| RB | Kalyn Grandberry | Jones (MS) | 5-11 | 198 | Fr. | |
| RB | Jaylen Warren | Snow (UT) | 5-8 | 222 | So. | |
| WR | Dontario Drummond | East Mississippi | 6-2 | 200 | So. | |
| WR | Nick Singleton | Iowa Western | 5-10 | 180 | So. | |
| TE | Devoniare Clarington | Northland (MN) | 6-7 | 230 | So. | |
| OL | Desmond Bland | Arizona Western | 6-3 | 290 | So. | |
| OL | Myron Cunningham | Iowa Central | 6-6 | 300 | So. | |
| OL | Bamidele Olaseni | Garden City (KS) | 6-8 | 340 | So. | |
| OL | Nick Paul | Kilgore (TX) | 6-6 | 385 | So. | |
| OL | Nick Radunz | North Dakoa SCS | 6-4 | 275 | Fr. | |
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| DL | Celestin Haba | Scottsdale (AZ) | 6-2 | 235 | So. | |
| DL | Elijah James | Iowa Western | 6-4 | 300 | So. | |
| DL | Samuel Okuayinonu | Mesabi Range (MN) | 6-2 | 270 | Fr. | |
| DL | Sam Williams | Northeast Mississippi | 6-5 | 265 | So. | |
| LB | Monty Montgomery | Hutchinson (KS) | 5-11 | 218 | Fr. | |
| LB | Damarkus Robins | Eastern Arizona | 5-10 | 215 | Fr. | |
| LB | Ali Shockley | Ellsworth (IA) | 5-10 | 185 | So. | |
| DB | JaQuan Brisker | Lackawanna (PA) | 6-1 | 193 | So. | |
| DB | Gervarrius Owens | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | 6-2 | 200 | Fr. | |
| DB | Fred Peters | Jones (MS) | 5-10 | 200 | So. | |
| DB | Damarion Williams | Highland (KS) | 5-11 | 175 | So. | |
| FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| K | Alfredo Marquez | Scottsdale (AZ) | 6-2 | 224 | So. | |
| P | Tommy Heatherly | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | 6-0 | 210 | So. | |
| RS | Tyrese Green | Phoenix (AZ) | 6-0 | 185 | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| QB | Craig Wells | Northland (MN) | 6-0 | 185 | Fr. | |
| RB | Deon McIntosh | East Mississippi | 5-11 | 195 | So. | |
| RB | Charles West | Garden City (KS) | 5-10 | 200 | So. | |
| WR | D'Monta Harris | Itasca (MN) | 5-9 | 174 | So. | |
| WR | Devin Neal | Scottsdale (AZ) | 6-0 | 171 | So. | |
| TE | Raymond Pauwels | Glendale (AZ) | 6-4 | 250 | So. | |
| OL | Blake Bedier | Snow (UT) | 6-6 | 275 | So. | |
| OL | Jalen Bell | Copiah-Lincoln (MS) | 6-5 | 330 | So. | |
| OL | Josh Cooper | Navarro (TX) | 6-6 | 350 | So. | |
| OL | Austin Lee | Georgia Military | 6-2 | 300 | So. | |
| OL | LaQuinston Sharp | East Mississippi | 6-4 | 310 | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| DL | Everitt Cunningham | East Mississippi | 6-3 | 250 | So. | |
| DL | Jacoby Jones | Butler (KS) | 6-4 | 250 | So. | |
| DL | Tevan McAdams | Trinity Valley (TX) | 6-3 | 240 | So. | |
| DL | Michael Slater | Iowa Central | 6-4 | 275 | So. | |
| LB | Chanler Ferguson | Tyler (TX) | 6-0 | 230 | So. | |
| LB | Tristan Murrin | Northland (MN) | 5-11 | 235 | Fr. | |
| LB | Willie O'Hara | Iowa Western | 6-2 | 230 | So. | |
| DB | Brandin Echols | Northwest Mississippi | 6-1 | 175 | So. | |
| DB | Taquelin Harris | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | 6-3 | 190 | So. | |
| DB | Daniel Isom | Iowa Western | 5-10 | 180 | So. | |
| DB | Quandre Mosely | Eastern Arizona | 6-1 | 185 | So. | |
| SECOND TEAM ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| K | Ryan Schemtob | Highland (KS) | 6-1 | 185 | So. | |
| P | Jared Stangler | Mesa (AZ) | 6-1 | 235 | So. | |
| RS | Michael Zachary | Iowa Western | 5-9 | 167 | So. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA OFFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| QB | Kare Lyles | Scottsdale (AZ) | 6-1 | 210 | Fr. | |
| QB | Messiah deWeaver | East Mississippi | 6-4 | 205 | So. | |
| RB | Dezmon Jackson | Hutchinson (KS) | 6-0 | 219 | So. | |
| RB | Dedrick Mills | Garden City (KS) | 5-11 | 215 | So. | |
| RB | Darran Williams | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M | 6-0 | 185 | So. | |
| WR | Jaelin Hood | Nassau (NY) | 6-1 | 180 | Fr. | |
| WR | Bradley Rozner | Cisco (TX) | 6-4 | 190 | So. | |
| WR | Jared Wyatt | Navarro (TX) | 6-2 | 195 | So. | |
| OL | Justin Calderon | Nassau (NY) | 6-3 | 285 | So. | |
| OL | Howard Watkins | Garden City (KS) | 6-4 | 295 | So. | |
| OL | Josh Weichel | Dupage (IL) | 6-6 | 305 | Fr. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA DEFENSE | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| DL | Atlias Bell | Iowa Western | 6-2 | 280 | So. | |
| DL | Marshaun Jones | North Dakota SCS | 6-0 | 260 | So. | |
| DL | Tevita Otuvaka | Arizona Western | 6-3 | 225 | So. | |
| DL | Ivin White | Hinds (MS) | 6-2 | 250 | So. | |
| DL | Parker Workman | Snow (UT) | 6-3 | 223 | So. | |
| LB | Nick Anderson | Jones (MS) | 5-10 | 232 | Fr. | |
| LB | DaQuan Cross | Iowa Central | 5-11 | 195 | Fr. | |
| LB | Reco Hannah | Highland (KS) | 6-2 | 220 | So. | |
| DB | Diarva Brown | Tyler (TX) | 5-11 | 180 | So. | |
| DB | Darryl Munoz | Mesabi Range (MN) | 6-1 | 195 | So. | |
| DB | Naeem Smith | Ellsworth (IA) | 5-11 | 185 | So. | |
| HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICA SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||||
| POS. | PLAYER | COLLEGE | HT | WT | CLASS | |
| K | Connor Cusick | Mesabi Range (MN) | 6-0 | 205 | So. | |
| RS | DJ Clayton | East Mississippi | 5-9 | 175 | So. | |
| RS | Rashad Tucker | Nassau (NY) | 5-10 | 180 | So. | |